Page 1 of 1

No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 12:48 pm
by fermnedoza
I just finished re-watching past editions of Miss Earth and can honestly say that I really wish Carousel will just stick to having the announcement of the top 8 as the final cut and from there the winners of the elemental and main crowns will be called.

Watching those editions were a final cut for a top 4 were made just made me feeling sad for the Miss Earth - Air winners as they were deprive of their own crowning moments; something that the winners of Fire and Water had.

Yes; I love the sight of a final two and the suspense and thrill of it all but the act of of just shoving the ME-Air winner to the side to be crowned while the entire focus of the cameras were all on the Miss Earth winner is just so disheartening.

So, unless Carousel Prod./MEO can give the ME-Air winner her moment of glory and TV exposure she deserve then it will be much better to call on the four winners from the top 8 like what they did on 2010, 2013 and similar editions.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 2:37 pm
by cocorocha
They only did that to miss earth philippines 2017 because abs cbn want the girm trend girl to be one of the last girl to announce winner

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 2:42 pm
by manoypoe
cocorocha wrote:They only did that to miss earth philippines 2017 because abs cbn want the girm trend girl to be one of the last girl to announce winner


VERY FAR ANSWER. YOU'RE OUT!!! [-X [-X

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 3:04 pm
by bcdf1930
SOMETHING TO LEARN FROM MW :)>-

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 3:34 pm
by fermnedoza
cocorocha wrote:They only did that to miss earth philippines 2017 because abs cbn want the girm trend girl to be one of the last girl to announce winner


It seemed to me you failed to get the gist of my post. I don't care how they arrange the order of announcement of the elemental court. I was talking about MEO's failure to give ME-Air her glory and on-cam crowning moment whenever they decided to have a top 4.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 3:47 pm
by manoypoe
bcdf1930 wrote:SOMETHING TO LEARN FROM MW :)>-


WHAT TO LEARN FROM MW? IS THERE?

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 5:44 pm
by sleuth08
fermnedoza wrote:I just finished re-watching past editions of Miss Earth and can honestly say that I really wish Carousel will just stick to having the announcement of the top 8 as the final cut and from there the winners of the elemental and main crowns will be called.

Watching those editions were a final cut for a top 4 were made just made me feeling sad for the Miss Earth - Air winners as they were deprive of their own crowning moments; something that the winners of Fire and Water had.

Yes; I love the sight of a final two and the suspense and thrill of it all but the act of of just shoving the ME-Air winner to the side to be crowned while the entire focus of the cameras were all on the Miss Earth winner is just so disheartening.

So, unless Carousel Prod./MEO can give the ME-Air winner her moment of glory and TV exposure she deserve then it will be much better to call on the four winners from the top 8 like what they did on 2010, 2013 and similar editions.


I'M ALL FOR THE RETURN OF THE 16-8 FORMAT.

I LIKE THE IDEA THE TOP 16 COMPETE IN SWIMSUIT AND EVENING GOWN THEN THE TOP 8 FOR THE FINAL QA

HOWEVER, I DID LIKE LAST YEAR WHEN THE TOP 8 COMPETED IN THE HASHTAG TALK THEN THE TOP 4 FOR THE FINAL QA

IF IT WILL BE A 16-8 FORMAT, THEN THE HASHTAG TALK WILL BE THE FINAL QA.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Fri Aug 04, 2017 12:18 pm
by fermnedoza
If Miss Earth will decide to still have a final 4 then I hope they follow the example of Man of the World where all the winners were given their moment during crowning.
[youtube]U2W2H2BNQHA[/youtube]

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Fri Aug 04, 2017 1:57 pm
by Sapphire
Nah. I want the top 4 Q&A. The likelihood for the winner to have a generic environmental answer is too high when it comes from the top 8.

The last 2 standing is also very thrilling coz more often than not I really want the other girl to win.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Fri Aug 04, 2017 4:38 pm
by manoypoe
Sapphire wrote:Nah. I want the top 4 Q&A. The likelihood for the winner to have a generic environmental answer is too high when it comes from the top 8.

The last 2 standing is also very thrilling coz more often than not I really want the other girl to win.


AGREE, AND IN ORDER FOR MISS AIR TO HAVE HER PROPER CROWNING MOMENT IS BY FOCUSING ON HER FIRST WHILE SHE IS BEING CROWNED AND SHIFT THE CAMERA TO THE MAIN CROWN WINNER AFTER MISS AIR IS SASHED AND CROWNED.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 3:42 am
by fermnedoza
manoypoe wrote:
Sapphire wrote:Nah. I want the top 4 Q&A. The likelihood for the winner to have a generic environmental answer is too high when it comes from the top 8.

The last 2 standing is also very thrilling coz more often than not I really want the other girl to win.


AGREE, AND IN ORDER FOR MISS AIR TO HAVE HER PROPER CROWNING MOMENT IS BY FOCUSING ON HER FIRST WHILE SHE IS BEING CROWNED AND SHIFT THE CAMERA TO THE MAIN CROWN WINNER AFTER MISS AIR IS SASHED AND CROWNED.


My sentiments exactly. I do not want seeing girl deprive of her moment of glory. Note that in my given example (Man of the World) the first runner-up was given his own moment before the limelight was given to the winner.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 5:06 pm
by Sapphire
I thought last year's crowning was alright.

Michelle wasn't totally ignored compared to the Miss Universe runner-ups

[youtube]StpMz_vuKRM[/youtube]
The cameraman was good at focusing on her and Katherine simultaneously.

Re: No More Top 4 at Miss Earth '17 Unless....

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2017 10:36 pm
by Diana Diane
[font=Courier New][color=#FF00FF][size=150]Pageants like Miss World, Grand, Binibining and Earth want to crown multiple girls with either runner up crowns and sashes or actual titles. THEREFORE they need to be responsable and give this girils the appropiate crown. It's beyond ridiculous [-X[/size][/color][/font]